Tuesday, April 23, 2013

Boating flare guns, or testicular terror?

Recently a Florida man, of course it's a Florida man, inadvertently or at least I hope so, shot himself in the groin with a marine flare gun. He subsequently required notable medical attention for damaged anatomy located in said region. So the question occurred to me, "What is the viability of using a marine flare gun as a weapon for self defense on a boat?"

You're sitting in a quiet anchorage when all of a sudden the boat is swarmed by zombies and pirates looking for rum. Your trusty 50 caliber machine gun is unfortunately disassembled and safely hidden out of sight from the gummit, laying under a foot of greasy black water in the bilge. All you have is your plastic orange flare gun, and six outdated 12 gauge red flares. With a glimmer of hope, you chamber a red flare. The trigger is pulled, and you fire at point blank range at the nearest zombie. The flare bounces off the zombie, and falls on the deck.

You, the zombies, and the pirates all stop at once blinded by  the ball of red light until in just seconds it burns through the deck and falls into the bilge water. The ensuing chemical reaction blows you backward off the boat now completely devoid of any eyebrows. Swimming away you try to keep your head real low to avoid your 50 cal ammunition that's now randomly hurling exploding bullets in all directions caused by the conflagration. A zombie near you tries to give you "the finger" as it flounders in the water but it falls off.

Two weeks later, you take a brown sharpie, and draw on eyebrows in preparation for the hearing. It seems that 400 gallons of diesel washed up on Longboat Key's shoreline, and the 50 caliber machine gun was found when the Coast Guard raised the boat. The Paradise Condo Association is upset about the bullet holes in the building's stucco, and a resident is claiming her Sphynx cat became so scared all of its hair fell out. There's even a zombie that's missing a finger and wearing a cheap suit who wants to testify. 

If you search around very few people have ever successfully used flare guns for defensive purposes. Mostly for those who have tried it, the end results tend to follow Murphy's laws of unintended circumstances. In the end, despite what you see in movies, it's a very poor choice for a weapon, especially on a boat full of fuel. It is however a great option for emergency distress signaling. 

The primary ingredients in a flare are black powder used to propel the flare to altitude, and Magnesium which provides the light. We will pause here for a moment to just consider this metal.

The property that makes magnesium good for flares is its very high burning temperature, of up to about 5600 F producing a bright light. The down side of magnesium is it's difficult to extinguish when burning. Throwing water on it makes the problem much worse. Not only does the water immediately turn to steam, but then the steam reacts with the burning magnesium creating hydrogen gas. Things instantly go from bad to much worse. Your typical small B & C boat fire extinguisher won't help here either. Only a class D fire extinguisher can put out a magnesium fire, and it should be a large one.

Other chemicals added to distress flares are various forms of strontium, and a oxidizer to help it burn. This creates the cheery red color.

I'm not going to belabor the point, but all recreational boats over 16' operating in coastal waters must carry USCG approved day and night visual distress signals. Manually powered boats, and open sailboats under 26' are excluded.

These can be pyrotechnic devices, or as simple as a distress flag, and an electric light that blinks SOS in morse code, as if anybody in this iPhone age actually remembers what this is. In the end three non-expired USCG approved red hand held flares meets the test for most boaters. Beyond that the prudent captain can make further decisions based on how and where they boat.

A couple pieces of advice. RTFD (Read the directions first) before you need to use them. Light and hold hand held flares over the water on the downwind side of the boat at an angle that won't let it drip hot stuff on your hands. Remember this stuff burns pretty hot. Shoot all aerial flares down wind, and not over land or other boats. Don't ever point a flare gun at your groin, or at anyone else even if you're joking.

Lastly check the expiration dates, and properly dispose of expired flares. By that I mean you can't take a bottle of rum and a bunch of expired red flares and fire them off in the bay with your buddies. It's illegal. The good news is you can do this with white flares, although I wouldn't have the rum on the boat when you're blasting away in these paranoid times. 

For those who would feel emasculated by using a cute feminine looking orange plastic flare gun, there are other options such as the manly B&D ExD 37mm Extreme Duty Top Break Launcher.

As scary as it looks it's legal, just as long as you only have 37mm flares on the boat. It can shoot a lot of other things too, but if that other ammunition is found on board it automatically becomes a weapon. I understand that Magnifico Yachts is giving one to each buyer of their new 2000 hp Phallic Fifty go fast boat as a buyer incentive. If you have one one of these on board, I would tell the USCG in advance of any inspections so they don't get too excited when they find it.

The photo of the 37mm launcher is from Wikipedia, and taken by user incitatus.
The small burning flare photo is from Wikipedia user Dvortygirl.
The flare gun photo is from Wikipedia by user MMX

7 comments:

  1. The dud(e) from Florida should just be glad that they weren't SOLAS flares... (longer burn times)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ammo will not explode and fragment in a fire.... And I just use a 12ga pump and a .40 S&W for defense, my flares are to alert rescuers...

    ReplyDelete
  3. You're right about loose ammo won't fire bullets, very far at any rate. They will explode however. I checked with the zombies who were there, and Mythbusters:

    http://mythbustersresults.com/episode85

    They empirically confirmed this, "Myth" Busted.

    Bullets in the chamber of a gun in a fire can and will fire off if it gets hot enough.

    Loose ammo just explodes and doesn't throw the bullet very far (it least it didn't escape the oven). The exploding shell casings can do damage. In either case I still wouldn't want to be in the hood while they were detonating.

    "Written visual imagery is a wonderful thing," quotes four finger zombie Clyde in a cheap suit.

    ReplyDelete
  4. jim caravan@mymts.netJanuary 11, 2014 at 8:27 AM

    For what it is worth: I am a proud and free living Canadian! But having said that I am not allowed to own or carry a .50 Cal. MG. Nor an assault rifle or a pistol. I cannot transport a hunting rifle or shotgun into or out of the USA without permits and hassle. In my boat and in my 37 foot RV I carry flare pistols primarily for emergency signalling, But if I am faced with someone threatening my family or property I am sure a well placed fireball will change the attitude of my oponent.
    Hopefully I am not stupid or careless enough to point a loaded and cocked weapon at my testicles.
    That victim of flared balls is lucky he wasnt playing with a .45 Colt automatic. The impact might have made him keep shooting in reflex and blown his legs off.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jim, thanks for the thoughts. The flare gun as a weapon has few historical examples of success, and many where Murphy's laws have seemed to be in control and cause unintended circumstances. The muzzle velocity is low, and very unlikely to do more than startle, rather than disable. The flare portion at close range will not yet have enough time to fully start deflagration. The end result is like I described. You and the attacker end up staring at the flare lying in your immediate vicinity, whether a boat or a RV. The flare will immediately try to ignite whatever it sitting on, and contact with water exacerbates the problem many-fold times. I think a Taser, stun gun, pepper spray, wasp spray, or a real gun are all likely to work with more efficacy. Here is the link to a fairly detailed examination of flare guns as a weapon.

      http://www.noedelscientific.com/user/flaregun1.pdf

      Delete
  5. jim caravan@mymts.netJanuary 11, 2014 at 1:56 PM

    Bill, I appreciate four comments my friend but since tasers, stunners, peppersparay, bear spray, real guns, spearguns, and slingshots are dimly viewed by the constabulary and border guards the flare gun is the only LEGAL thing I can carry besides a knife, and my backup one my thug is dazzled or startled by the flare is a sharp machete. If he is farther away I have a 4' blowgun fitted with a laser dot sight.
    But then after 54 years travelling in 16 countries I have never once really needed a .45 or any other weapon of ball busting capabilities. When in the boonies in southern USA or aboard my boat I do have a blade resembling a Bowie on my hip but that is for filleting mosquitoes.
    The flare gun may not be much but its what I have.
    Now if someone had a .38 they wanted to part with quietly I might be tempted.

    ReplyDelete
  6. jim caravan@mymts.netJanuary 11, 2014 at 2:19 PM

    And Bill, seriously, have you ever looked at a "pen" type pocket flare launcher? Now that presents a whole different scenario.
    Looking at a spent flare casing for that puppy brought on an idea. The base of the flare has a blank rimfire of just about .22 cal. It wouldn't take much to punch out the primer and a little file work would let a .22 long rifle just drop in. Granted the casing would likely burst inside the flare housing but with a range measured in inches it would beat hell out of a flare burning on the deck.
    Damn, maybe I should see if I can find a flex-mount 20 MM Oerlikon for the bow of my Silverline a .50 for the stern and a couple of 37 MM launchers loaded with HE frag shells. Then a couple of M-16s in case it gets to close up stuff. Of couse a couple of cases of M36 grenades might help, /

    ReplyDelete